Frogs are no plague
Quote from Herodion on October 8, 2026, 10:21 amA talk I had with Janardana led us to an interesting question. It is said that killing a frog is worse than killing a human: you can atone for the sin of murder in this lifetime, unless it’s a frog, in which case it is impossible. Being that no obvious explanation was offered, I will present the multiple angles we discovered in our discussion, hoping to foster conversation.
1. Parvati is fond of turning people into frogs, either as a curse, to punish disrespect, or both. Consider a Nepalese story, in which a group of brahmins witnesses (or even ridicules) Shiva-Shakti at the moment of union, causing Parvati to turn all of them into frogs. Additionally, Madhura is cursed to become a frog for making love with Shiva in Parvati’s absence. After this penance of 12 years, she earns enough merit to become Mandodari, the wife of Ravana.
2. Frogs save sages from poisoning in many traditions. Specifically, in parts of Eastern India, it is said that they prevent sages from drinking poisoned milk. This could be the source of their boon: what else could warrant species-wide merit if not saving a sage from sinking into impurity and half-knowledge? It must be mentioned, however, that the sages first curse the frogs: in the story of Mandar and Udar, the frog who jumps into the milk is first perceived as greedy, but after the sages realise they were rash, the curse is reversed, and frogs invariably assume the form of “beautiful maidens”. When the wise men look beyond with discernment, they become aware of a key tantric principle: uncleanliness is often purity disguised. Furthermore, what they thought to be sattva and purity was actually poison! Only the seemingly villainous frog allowed them to be saved from delusion, just like the terrifying Kali, born of the poison swallowed by Shiva, suckles Rudra and pacifies the enemies of the gods.
3. A very specific form of Palden Lhamo, the guardian goddess of Tibet, is frog faced and considered to be an ugra form of Lakshmi.
4. One of the 64 yoginis, Jalakamini, has a frog as her vahana.
5. Rigveda (RV 7.103) shows us the Frog Hymn (Manduka Sukta). A very interesting composition, in which frogs are compared to a student chanting the Veda and brahmins receiving Soma. One is the cow, one is the calf, one is the frog, one is the speaker / They are called by various names, though one in form / . . . / They who are like purified brahmins . . . / . . . / The frogs have given us a thousand gifts, and hundred, and ten.
6. Finally, concerning the gross level. These animals are amphibians, neither here nor there, and have an innate attunement to sandhya, croaking to signal rainfall. Frogs are also very useful creatures for our ecosystems, living long lives and only interfering with beings typically seen as malicious to human activity, such as disease carrying mosquitos. Surely the work of frogs has been a blessing for areas struggling against malaria. Additionally, since we are both passionate about comparative studies and syncretism, we’ve also brought up incidences of frogs in mythology: consider the biblical plague, frogs with psychedelic venom on the American continent (whose mystical traditions hinge heavily on use of hallucinogenic plants), and the early Egyptian frog goddess Heqet – besides her similarity with Hekate, she fulfills a motherly Devi role and rules over magic, fertility and resurrection, more pronounced especially in her later evolution of Hathor.
A talk I had with Janardana led us to an interesting question. It is said that killing a frog is worse than killing a human: you can atone for the sin of murder in this lifetime, unless it’s a frog, in which case it is impossible. Being that no obvious explanation was offered, I will present the multiple angles we discovered in our discussion, hoping to foster conversation.
1. Parvati is fond of turning people into frogs, either as a curse, to punish disrespect, or both. Consider a Nepalese story, in which a group of brahmins witnesses (or even ridicules) Shiva-Shakti at the moment of union, causing Parvati to turn all of them into frogs. Additionally, Madhura is cursed to become a frog for making love with Shiva in Parvati’s absence. After this penance of 12 years, she earns enough merit to become Mandodari, the wife of Ravana.
2. Frogs save sages from poisoning in many traditions. Specifically, in parts of Eastern India, it is said that they prevent sages from drinking poisoned milk. This could be the source of their boon: what else could warrant species-wide merit if not saving a sage from sinking into impurity and half-knowledge? It must be mentioned, however, that the sages first curse the frogs: in the story of Mandar and Udar, the frog who jumps into the milk is first perceived as greedy, but after the sages realise they were rash, the curse is reversed, and frogs invariably assume the form of “beautiful maidens”. When the wise men look beyond with discernment, they become aware of a key tantric principle: uncleanliness is often purity disguised. Furthermore, what they thought to be sattva and purity was actually poison! Only the seemingly villainous frog allowed them to be saved from delusion, just like the terrifying Kali, born of the poison swallowed by Shiva, suckles Rudra and pacifies the enemies of the gods.
3. A very specific form of Palden Lhamo, the guardian goddess of Tibet, is frog faced and considered to be an ugra form of Lakshmi.
4. One of the 64 yoginis, Jalakamini, has a frog as her vahana.
5. Rigveda (RV 7.103) shows us the Frog Hymn (Manduka Sukta). A very interesting composition, in which frogs are compared to a student chanting the Veda and brahmins receiving Soma. One is the cow, one is the calf, one is the frog, one is the speaker / They are called by various names, though one in form / . . . / They who are like purified brahmins . . . / . . . / The frogs have given us a thousand gifts, and hundred, and ten.
6. Finally, concerning the gross level. These animals are amphibians, neither here nor there, and have an innate attunement to sandhya, croaking to signal rainfall. Frogs are also very useful creatures for our ecosystems, living long lives and only interfering with beings typically seen as malicious to human activity, such as disease carrying mosquitos. Surely the work of frogs has been a blessing for areas struggling against malaria. Additionally, since we are both passionate about comparative studies and syncretism, we’ve also brought up incidences of frogs in mythology: consider the biblical plague, frogs with psychedelic venom on the American continent (whose mystical traditions hinge heavily on use of hallucinogenic plants), and the early Egyptian frog goddess Heqet – besides her similarity with Hekate, she fulfills a motherly Devi role and rules over magic, fertility and resurrection, more pronounced especially in her later evolution of Hathor.
Quote from CuriousBoar on October 8, 2026, 6:04 pmFrom an interpretive point of view, the frog’s jumping could also be seen as a symbolic movement beyond the three ordinary states of consciousness—waking, dreaming, and deep sleep—towards Turīya, the fourth state.
There’s another interesting layer in the Ṛgvedic Māṇḍūka Sūkta. Frogs begin croaking with the arrival of the rains, and are described as being stirred by Parjanya, the Vedic deity of rain. This can be read symbolically: when the dryness of avidyā prevails, the frogs remain silent. Then, as the divine impulse of Parjanya reaches them, they awaken and begin to croak—just as the Brāhmaṇas, awakened by divine inspiration, begin to recite and sing the Vedas. Their voices then become almost like a announcement of the coming rain of divinity, breaking the dryness of ignorance.
It’s a fascinating interpretive layer, especially because the Māṇḍūka Sūkta itself leaves so much room for symbolism. This particular connection doesn’t seem to be discussed as much as one might expect😅
From an interpretive point of view, the frog’s jumping could also be seen as a symbolic movement beyond the three ordinary states of consciousness—waking, dreaming, and deep sleep—towards Turīya, the fourth state.
There’s another interesting layer in the Ṛgvedic Māṇḍūka Sūkta. Frogs begin croaking with the arrival of the rains, and are described as being stirred by Parjanya, the Vedic deity of rain. This can be read symbolically: when the dryness of avidyā prevails, the frogs remain silent. Then, as the divine impulse of Parjanya reaches them, they awaken and begin to croak—just as the Brāhmaṇas, awakened by divine inspiration, begin to recite and sing the Vedas. Their voices then become almost like a announcement of the coming rain of divinity, breaking the dryness of ignorance.
It’s a fascinating interpretive layer, especially because the Māṇḍūka Sūkta itself leaves so much room for symbolism. This particular connection doesn’t seem to be discussed as much as one might expect😅





